First of all, why such a prude? 17-19 yr olds aren’t just pecking or having their first kiss. Secondly, what a ridiculously dissatisfying ending. It’s almost as if you simply gave up towards the end. For shame.

Really enjoyed the first, second, and third. I was just disappointed when _________ & __________ turned out to be gay. Maybe it was hard to bring in more characters because you really brought everyone to life. It seemed more like love of a family than lovers.

One of my favorite series! Wholly unique!

Good storyline. Terrible anticlimactic ending.

After a promising first book and a great second, the third was mediocre and this was terrible. Horrible start, decent build up, even worse ending.

In varying degrees of horror, shock, joy, and composure basically sums up my reaction to the conclusion of the series. I laughed, but mostly I cried. Stiefvater is my favorite author for a good reason.

It's here. It's really here. Okay. Come at me, Stevivater! 😩👌