In this volume published in 1935, American writer Edward Sylvester Ellis provides a youth’s dictionary of Greek and Roman mythology, with brief descriptions of mythological characters in alphabetical order.
Reviews
Leaves A Lot To Be Desired
2
By A.W. Reese
It is obvious, reading this, that the author mainly focuses on Greco-Roman myth.
That’s all well and good. The problem is that the title gave me the impression that the author would describe characters from all over the world in a decent amount of detail.
He only describes the Greco-Roman characters in any amount of detail, and even then he gets some things wrong, like Hecate being an aspect of Persephone (they’re two separate characters; in fact, Hecate helped Demeter look for Persephone).
Other characters barely get a sentence’s worth of mention. Hindu (or Hindoo, as he spells it) deities’ entries go like this:
“Brahma - creator of the universe.”
And that’s it. Celtic and Nordic deities’ entries also lack information, and some of the information is just flat-out wrong. Huginn and Muninn weren’t gods; they were simply the ravens of Odin, symbolizing thought and memory. If you read either of the Eddas, you’ll know that Snorri Sturluson never calls them gods.
My advice: read the holy texts of whichever mythology you’re interested in, and not this. A book like this should give the same amount of attention to all of the mythologies it aims to cover, rather than only a couple of them.
Comments
Advertisement
Maximize your website's potential with Website Statistic
Get insights into your website traffic, analyze your website's audience, and optimize your website for better results with Website Statistic.